Blackout Tire Shine vs All Dressed Up – Which Looks Better and Lasts Longer?

Both promise clean, dark tire sidewalls—but the formula, finish, and longevity tell two very different stories. So which one actually holds up: Blackline’s Blackout Tire Shine or Jimbo’s All Dressed Up?

In this post, we compare shine level, application experience, sling, and durability to help you choose the right product for your tire care routine.

What They’re Designed to Do

Both products aim to restore a rich black finish to rubber, vinyl, and trim. But how they do it—and how long they last—differs big time.

• Blackline Blackout Tire Dressing: Described as a high-shine formula that dries to the touch.
• All Dressed Up: A water-based, matte/satin OEM-style dressing designed for both interiors and exteriors.

Application and Finish Comparison

🖌️ Blackline Blackout Tire Shine

• Applies thick, with a greasy feel
• High gloss out of the bottle
• May require buffing to reduce sling

✨ All Dressed Up

• Applies easily with a foam pad or brush
• Dries dry to the touch
• Leaves a rich, non-greasy black finish

Key Difference: If you prefer a more natural, factory-new tire look without sling, All Dressed Up is the smarter choice.

Durability and Weather Resistance

We applied both dressings to two identical tires and drove through 3 summer washes and 1 rainy day:

• Blackline: Shine dropped noticeably after 2 days. Sling was present after the first drive.
• All Dressed Up: Matte finish held for over a week, with no sling or residue on paint panels.

Bonus: All Dressed Up can also be used on engine bays, interior plastics, and exterior trim—giving you more for your money.

Want a Clean, OEM Look?

If high-gloss isn’t your style, All Dressed Up gives you that perfect 'new car tire' finish—no streaks, no mess, no worries. It’s also water-based and safe for PPF, plastics, rubber, and more.