Blackline Tire Applicator vs All Blacked Out Pads – Grip, Finish, and Price Compared

Q: Is the Blackline Tire Applicator worth the price?

It’s a decent tool, but expensive for what it is. The handle can be awkward, and the foam pad is thin. You can get more value and better coverage with the All Blacked Out Pads.

Q: What’s the best applicator for tire dressing?

Look for a dense foam block like the All Blacked Out Pad. It offers full contact with the tire surface, absorbs less product, and gives a streak-free finish.

Q: Can I use the All Blacked Out Pads on trim too?

Yes. These pads work great for dressing exterior trim, interior plastics, and even engine bay surfaces. They’re washable and reusable.

When it comes to applying tire dressing, the applicator matters just as much as the product. So how does Blackline’s Tire Brush compare to the All Blacked Out Pads from Jimbo’s Detailing?

In this post, we test both side-by-side for comfort, coverage, streaking, and price—so you can choose the smarter tool for clean, even tire shine every time.

What They Are

🖌️ Blackline Tire Applicator Brush

Hard plastic handle + curved foam pad
Designed for tire sidewalls and trim
Price: ~$14–16

🧽 All Blacked Out Applicator Pad

Dense, closed-cell foam block (no handle)
Contoured to fit hand comfortably
Flat face = even product distribution
Price: $13.99 (4-pack)

Key difference? One relies on a handle, the other gives direct control in your hand with more even contact.

Application & Comfort

Blackline: Handle looks sleek but feels bulky in hand. Grip can get slippery with dressing on gloves. Foam pad is replaceable but thin.
All Blacked Out Pads: Fits in palm comfortably. No slippage. Foam is thicker and flexible enough to conform to any sidewall curve.

With the Blacked Out Pads, you apply less pressure and still get full contact—no missed spots or uneven dressing lines.

Finish & Streaking

We used both tools to apply a water-based dressing to clean tires:

Blackline: Left thin streaks along edges. Took more product to get even coverage.
All Blacked Out: Smooth finish, no sling, no ridges. Better product control and less waste.

Pro Tip: Don’t overload the pad. A little dressing goes a long way when the foam density is right.

More Than Just Tires

The All Blacked Out Pads aren’t just for tires. They also work great on:

Trim dressing
Interior rubber and vinyl
Engine bay plastics

At under $4 per pad, you get more utility and longer-lasting value.

Grip Better. Apply Cleaner. Spend Less.

Why pay more for one brush when you can get four high-quality applicator pads that do more—with better control and even coverage every time?

Buy All Blacked Out Pads