Picture Perfect Polish vs 3D ONE vs P&S Rehab – Which One-Step Polish Delivers Real Results?
One-step polishes promise to save time and deliver results—but not all of them live up to the hype. In this test, we compared:
- Picture Perfect Polish – Jimbo’s Detailing
- 3D ONE – A long-trusted hybrid compound/polish
- P&S Rehab – Reconditioning Cream used widely in production detailing
We tested all three on black and soft clear coats using DA polishers with various pad combos. The results were surprising.
Polish Comparison – At a Glance
| Product | Cut Level | Finish Quality | Dusting | Working Time | Pad Flexibility |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Picture Perfect Polish | ✅ High with cutting pad | ✅ Flawless, haze-free | ✅ Zero dust | ✅ Long and consistent | ✅ Works great with all pads |
| 3D ONE | Moderate | Good but may haze soft paint | ❌ Light-to-moderate dust | Moderate working time | Best with medium foam |
| P&S Rehab | Low-to-moderate | Glossy finish but less clarity | ❌ Moderate dusting | Short work cycle, dries fast | Less responsive to pad change |
Correction Power
Picture Perfect Polish offered noticeably better defect removal on both test panels. With a microfiber cutting pad, it corrected deeper swirls and scratches in one pass. 3D ONE was capable, but needed more pressure and a second pass. P&S Rehab left much of the damage behind—more of a light cleaner than a true correction compound.
Finishing Ability
Only Picture Perfect Polish finished clean and streak-free on both hard and soft paints. 3D ONE left minor haze on black paint when overworked, and P&S Rehab had some oily residue that required a second wipe with an IPA to reveal the true finish.
Dusting & Clean-Up
Picture Perfect Polish: Zero dust. Smooth wipe-off every time.
3D ONE: Some light dust, especially with long passes on rotary tools.
P&S Rehab: Dry product with significant dust and chalky residue.
Customer Testimonials
"Rehab was fine for quick dealership work, but when I tried Picture Perfect Polish, the difference was night and day. More cut, way better finish."
– Matt C., Ohio
"I’ve used 3D ONE for years, but I’m switching to Picture Perfect. No dust, faster correction, and a cleaner finish with less effort."
– Trevor S., Washington
Final Verdict – One-Step Winner
Picture Perfect Polish is the clear winner in this showdown. Whether you're working on soft or hard paint, using a DA or rotary, it offers maximum versatility, no dusting, and unmatched clarity.
If you’re ready to replace two or three polishes with one that actually works—this is it.
