Carfidant Ultimate Car Cleaner vs. Pure Magic – Which One Actually Works?
Carfidant markets their “Ultimate Car Cleaner” as an all-in-one solution for interior and exterior surfaces. But how does it compare to a professional-grade wheel and tire cleaner like Pure Magic? We put both to the test in real-world conditions—and the results were very clear.
What Is Carfidant Ultimate Car Cleaner?
This is a general-purpose cleaner you can use on seats, dashboards, paint, trim, wheels—you name it. It’s positioned as a safe, do-it-all spray for everyday use.
Pros:
- Safe on a wide range of surfaces
- Good for light cleaning tasks
- No strong chemical smell
Cons:
- Weak cleaning power on heavy grime
- Not ideal for wheels, tires, or brake dust
- No foam or dwell time for deep cleaning
What Is Pure Magic Cleaner?
Pure Magic is a pro-grade acid-based cleaner that melts brake dust, browns tires, and restores factory freshness to neglected wheels, rubber, and trim.
It’s also a secret weapon when diluted as a foam cannon soap booster.
Pros:
- Removes heavy brake dust and mineral deposits
- Deep-cleans tires and plastics
- Acid-based bite = pro results
- Foam cannon compatible when diluted
Cons:
- Not meant for interiors
- Shouldn’t be used on raw aluminum or delicate finishes
Head-to-Head Test: Tires & Wheels
We cleaned two equally dirty wheels—one with Carfidant, one with Pure Magic.
- Carfidant: Removed surface dust, but couldn’t tackle browning or stuck-on brake dust.
- Pure Magic: Lifted embedded grime, restored black rubber, and left wheels looking freshly detailed.
The difference in foam, dwell time, and cleaning power was night and day.
Use Case Breakdown
| Task | Carfidant Cleaner | Pure Magic Cleaner |
|---|---|---|
| Light interior wipe downs | ✅ | ❌ |
| Brake dust removal | ❌ | ✅ |
| Tire browning removal | ❌ | ✅ |
| Plastic trim refresh | ⚠️ | ✅ |
| Foam cannon additive | ❌ | ✅ |
Verdict: Safe and Simple vs. Powerful and Professional
If you’re just looking for a light-duty cleaner that’s safe for almost any surface, Carfidant might be a fit. But if you want to tackle real grime—on wheels, tires, plastics, and trim—Pure Magic is the tool for the job.
Want even better results? Follow up with All Dressed Up for a clean, matte tire and trim finish that lasts.
Shop the Combo
Related Posts
- Carfidant Scratch Remover vs. Picture Perfect Polish
- Foam Cannon vs. Pump Sprayer
- Complete Cabin Cleaner – Deep Interior Cleaning Without Streaks
